Skip to content
Capilano Courier
Menu
  • Home
  • Sections
    • News
    • Features & The Profile
    • Community
    • Arts & Culture
    • Humour
    • Video Production
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
  • Meet the Crew
  • Online Issues
  • Subscribe!
Menu

Of Nips and Cultural Crit

Posted on February 18, 2019February 15, 2019 by Taylor Kleine-Deters

Super Bowl halftime show nipples inspire discourse and memes

Taylor Kleine-Deters, Contributor

With an event that was shrouded in social and political undertones from the get-go, expectations for Super Bowl LIII drama were high. What was not anticipated was the intense chatter about nipples and the societal distaste for them being visible on women versus being considered inoffensive on men.

From New Orleans Saints fans and allies of Colin Kaepernick who boycotted the event, to NFL fans who were tired of seeing the New England Patriots play, there were fewer viewers for this year’s event coming in around the 100 million viewer mark – one of the lowest ratings for the “biggest game” in recent history. Of course, apart from the sport and the commercials, there are typically hundreds of thousands of people who will view the game simply for the halftime show. This year, not so much.

The viewers that did watch were subject to a performance by Maroon 5 that was objectively not bad, but definitely lacked some of the more zany excess that has become standard fare for the Super Bowl halftime. The one thing that got people talking about Maroon 5, apart from the ‘white dad-dancing’ that frontman Adam Levine did while standing alongside Travis Scott and Big Boi, was Levine’s shedding of his many layers of clothing. By the end of the 13-minute set, Levine was bare-chested and heaving with exertion. His nipples and full array of tragic flash tattoos were the central focus of prime-time television for approximately three minutes.

Immediately the Internet was abuzz recalling the incident from the 2004 Super Bowl in Houston, Texas when Janet Jackson’s right breast was exposed by Justin Timberlake in what was cited to be a “shocking” wardrobe malfunction. The split second that Jackson’s breast and embellished nipple were exposed on television cast a black cloud upon her reputation. She was forced to issue an apology for the incident immediately and was reportedly banned from the 2004 Grammy Awards. Some people believe that her induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame was pushed back for years due to the incident as well as the consistent blacklisting that she received because of it.

In the age of streaming music, Maroon 5 stands seemingly unaffected. Boring performance and topless “controversy” aside – the band’s entire discography is reported to have experienced a 488 per cent sales gain. The only lasting impression that Levine’s shirtless halftime antics seems to be that he became an instant meme.

In a time of banning female-presenting nipples and the rise of politicized feminism, it seems inevitable that nipples would be the lasting impression from a lacklustre and crushingly middle-of-the-road performance. Jackson being vilified for something as innocuous as a nip-slip 15 years after it happened seems even more absurd when Levine can willfully expose his chest and get yawned at. There seems to be a double standard at work here.

So, with an incredibly musically talented woman of colour’s reputation still being maligned 15 years later for a slight that in any other context would be considered assault, the question becomes: why is a white man’s PG-rated strip tease worth talking about? This is worth considering because it is incredibly easy to observe cultural happenings and forget about them in favour of the next shock-value culture piece of news. As consumers of mainstream media, it is an invaluable skill to recognize societal, racial and sexual inequalities as they are presented. Critical consumption and awareness will lend itself to making much of this world a more comfortable place for all humans to thrive in their diversity. Simply asking questions and analyzing privilege is a good starting platform for the race toward equality.

Category: Opinions

Post navigation

← “Let’s Talk” About Self-Care Privilege
Public Consultation for CapU Smoking Policies Imminent →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

  • Challenging Colonial and Patriarchal Structures in Academia
    An interview with Dr. Vicki St. Pierre, CapU’s new Provost & Vice-President Academic Written by Asmi Toor Sogi (she/her) // News Writer […]
  • Who Broke the Fall When International Enrolment Collapsed?
    The quiet disappearance of non-regular faculty across the province and the diffusion of responsibility among governments and institutions […]
  • Capilano University Was Not Named After Chief Joe Capilano
    The university has corrected its land acknowledgment amid claims of historical inaccuracy Written by Sara Derksen (they/them) // News […]
  • CapU Library Reduces Operating Hours as University Confronts Deficit
    An interview with Interim University Librarian Sabrina Wong Written by Xiadany Jeanette Lopez Hernandez (she/her) // News Writer Visuals by […]
  • Meet the New Chancellor
    Debra Doucette became the new chancellor of CapU in June 2026. The Courier had the opportunity to interview her about her new role and her […]
  • No AI in Vancouver
    The Fight Against AI data Centres Sara Derksen (they/them) // News Editor Lily Jones (she/her)// Contributing Visuals There is a growing […]
Video Production
On October 3rd, 2026, hundreds of people joined the march organized by No Ai Vancouver—a grassroots movement that was founded to prevent the construction of Artificial Intelligence (AI) data centres in Metro Vancouver. Join Asmi, our news writer, to find out what inspired people to protest.

Read more about the No Ai Movement at capilanocourier.com/2026/10/01/no-ai-in-vancouver/
International Day of Protest Against AI (Vancouver)
Subscribe
What even is a Zine? Mia shows us a behind the scene of how this little publication comes together, the vision behind it, and how to become a paid contributor of the C.C. Crumb!
Indigenous power means something different to every student, but it always begins with voice, community, and truth. Hear what CapU students had to say.
What does campus clean-up day look like?
© 2026 Capilano Courier | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme